Do Performance-Based Bonuses Work?

Do Performance-Based Bonuses Work?

To better understand the impact of performance-based bonuses, we asked 10 professionals from various industries and positions, including CEOs, marketing managers, and community experts. From discussing the negative effects on employees to addressing problems with performance bonuses, these experts provide valuable insights into the effectiveness and potential downsides of this popular compensation strategy.

  • Negative Effects on Employees
  • Powerful Motivators and Retention
  • Effectiveness of Various Bonuses
  • Fairness in Performance Bonuses
  • Differentiation and Non-Monetary Rewards
  • Effectiveness and Potential Downsides
  • Factors Affecting Bonus Effectiveness
  • Influence on Employee Behavior
  • Hindering Collaboration
  • Problems With Performance Bonuses

Negative Effects on Employees

Although logic dictates that performance bonuses should be a great incentive for employees to work harder, it rarely works at all. They also often do a number on the employees seeking to get that performance boost and overwork themselves. They usually are highly stressed out and their job satisfaction drops considerably.

Natalia BrzezinskaNatalia Brzezinska
Marketing and Outreach Manager, ePassportPhoto

Powerful Motivators and Retention

They can be powerful motivators because they reward people who show excellent skills and a firm commitment to achieving set goals and objectives. These types of rewards help create an environment where high performance is recognized and reinforced, which encourages others to strive for success as well.

This type of bonus system also allows managers greater flexibility in recognizing accomplishments beyond regular salary increases that occur at predetermined intervals throughout the year. Also, study after study has proven time after time that those who receive good remuneration packages stay longer with companies—something especially important when trying to keep top talent.

Roksana BieleckaRoksana Bielecka
Community Manager, ResumeHelp

Effectiveness of Various Bonuses

When directly linked to a metric that is easily measurable, performance-based bonuses can be a great motivator for hard work and longevity within an organization. However, not all performance-based bonuses need to involve money—offering team-building activities like paintballing can help foster relationships among colleagues and strengthen their sense of camaraderie, which is not something that cash rewards can achieve. This example shows how non-monetary bonuses can still provide motivating incentives for employees to reach their goals.

Carly HillCarly Hill
Operations Manager, Virtual Holiday Party

Fairness in Performance Bonuses

Performance-based bonuses are a good way to reward employees to work harder and better. However, the bonuses need to be fair and commensurate with the employee’s performance. Otherwise, it will cause resentment and lead to poor morale.

For example, if an employee consistently performs well and never misses deadlines, they should be rewarded more than someone who only performs marginally. The same goes for sales-based bonuses. An employee who sells a lot of products or services should be rewarded more than someone who sells less.

Matthew RamirezMatthew Ramirez
CEO, Paraphrase Tool

Differentiation and Non-Monetary Rewards

Performance-based bonuses are most effective when award amounts are significantly differentiated by performance level. Employees should be reassured that their efforts will be proportionately rewarded. For example, employees who are top performers may receive twice the bonus target amount that their average counterparts receive.

As you consider investing in top performers, remember to include non-monetary rewards to complement their bonus payments, such as extra time off, enrollment in development programs, or awards and public recognition.

It may be appropriate to penalize low performers by only paying half of their bonus target. By introducing variability in payouts, employees will be dissuaded from underperforming. Without meaningful payment variation, employees may conclude that the organization does not value their extraordinary contributions, and that belief might influence how they perform as they try to create a sense of balance for themselves.

Tyren ThompsonTyren Thompson
Compensation Partner, Zoom

Effectiveness and Potential Downsides

I can say that performance-based bonuses can be effective in motivating employees to perform at their best. When structured properly, bonuses can encourage employees to work harder, increase productivity, and meet or exceed goals. However, it is important to remember that bonuses should not be the sole motivator for employees and should be viewed as supplemental rewards.

It’s also important to consider the potential downsides of performance-based bonuses. If not executed fairly or if the criteria for earning the bonus are unclear, it can create a negative and competitive work environment.

Bonuses may not be effective in motivating employees who already feel undervalued or underpaid. To ensure that performance-based bonuses work, it’s important to have clear and objective criteria for earning the bonus and to provide regular feedback to employees to help them understand how their performance contributes to the company’s overall success.

Luciano ColosLuciano Colos
Founder and CEO, PitchGrade

Factors Affecting Bonus Effectiveness

Performance-based bonuses can be effective in motivating employees and improving performance in some contexts. However, the effectiveness of this approach may depend on factors such as the type of work being performed and the design of the bonus program.

Some studies have found that performance-based bonuses can improve productivity and performance in tasks that are relatively straightforward. For more complex and creative tasks, performance-based bonuses may actually harm productivity and reduce the quality of work.

This is because such tasks often require intrinsic motivation, and introducing external rewards can crowd out intrinsic motivation, leading to a decrease in performance. The bonuses may create a competitive atmosphere that can harm team cohesion and collaboration.

Brenton ThomasBrenton Thomas
CEO, Twibi Digital Marketing Agency

Influence on Employee Behavior

Performance-based bonuses are probably one of the best approaches to incentive compensation.

Keeping in mind that incentive compensation isn’t guaranteed, by creating a performance-based program, you are establishing a clear metric for what “good looks like”, and employees know if they perform to set goals, they can influence their own income.

Because they perform well, the business makes more money, and because the business makes more money, they can meet or exceed financial goals. And because the company meets its financial goals, it can fund the bonus pool. The employee can share in company gains.

This is one of the strongest examples of the idea that compensation influences behavior. If you reward powerful performance through an incentive bonus program, and employees reap the benefits of the program, it stands to reason they will continue to meet performance goals to further benefit from the bonus program.

Eric MochnaczEric Mochnacz
Director of Operations, Red Clover

Hindering Collaboration

Performance-based bonuses can breed a sense of competition in employees that should otherwise be focused on working together. Depending on your business, your teams or even individuals within a single team may feel that earning a bonus specific to their personal success takes priority over making sure the job is right.

This can lead to lacking collaboration between teams and teammates, as well as an unwillingness to help others in achieving overall success for the company. While performance-based incentives seem nice on the surface, they can be too much for many businesses, especially those that thrive on close collaboration between all of their moving parts.

Max SchwartzapfelMax Schwartzapfel
CMO, Schwartzapfel Lawyers

Problems With Performance Bonuses

Contrary to the common belief, performance-based bonuses do not guarantee better overall performance of the business.

One reason is that such a solution requires excellent management skills, transparency, and flawless implementation of work ethics. Why is it so important? The reason is that the individuals who aren’t rewarded often feel underappreciated and unmotivated to make more of an effort than required, the phenomenon recently called “quiet quitting”.

Plus, what about the fields where performance is not easily measurable? And what about circumstantial factors which may disrupt the performance despite the employee’s best efforts?

Overachievers will definitely hit their targets with flying colors. Although the concept of distinguishing the most efficient employees sounds simple, we should think about the big picture and the ultimate results.

Martyna SzczesniakMartyna Szczesniak
Community Expert, MyPerfectResume

Submit Your Answer

Would you like to submit an alternate answer to the question, “Do performance-based bonuses work? Why or why not?”

Submit your answer here.